I am attending a course on Udemy and one of the exercises is to return all the prime numbers from a range of numbers (for example all prime numbers before 100)
This is the query that the teacher made
def count_primes2(num):
#Check for 1 or 0
if num < 2:
return 0
######################
#2 or greater
#Store our prime numbers
primes = [2] #I start my list with 2 that is a prime number
#Counter going up to the input num
x = 3 #I create a variable on which I will continue adding until I reach num
# x is going through every number up to the input num
while x <= num:
#Check if x is prime
for y in range(3,x,2): # for y in range from 3 to x in even steps, we only wantto check odd numbers there
if x%y == 0:
x += 2
break
else:
primes.append(x)
x += 2
print(primes)
return len(primes)
count_primes2(100)
However, I came up with the one below that is not working. My idea is:
Given each number i between between 3 and num+1 (for example 100 would be 101 so that 100 can be included in the calculation):
Open a for loop in which I divide i by each number g before i (including i) and I have a counter checking when this division gives no remainder. This implies that in case of prime numbers the counter should always be 2 (for example 3--> 3:1 and 3:3 would give remainder 0).
If the counter is equal to 2, then i is a prime and I want to append it to the list.
I am not using any while loop in my query. Can you help me to identify why my query is not working?
def count_prime(num):
counter=0
list_prime=[2]
if num<2:
return 0
for i in range(3,num+1):
for g in range(1,i+1):
if i%g==0:
counter+=1
if counter==2:
list_prime.append(i)
return list_prime
count_prime(100)
Kudos to Khelwood for the help. Below the working query:
def count_prime(num):
counter=0
list_prime=[2]
if num<2:
return 0
for i in range(3,num+1):
for g in range(1,i+1):
if i%g==0:
counter+=1
if counter==2:
list_prime.append(i)
counter=0
return list_prime
count_prime(100)
you may do this :
for i in range(2,num):
if (num % i) == 0:`
Instead of using two for loops, you can simply eliminate one of the for loop and do this, I hope this may work for you.
thankyou.
Related
This is my code. I am trying to find the prime numbers before or equal to the integer inputted. However, it seems that the loop stops when it sees an integer in the range that fits the requirements. Unfortunately, this is not I wanted it to do. I would like to make it run through all the tests in the range before making the judgement. Is this possible? If so, how do I do this? Thank you.
def getNumber(main):
n = int(input())
return n
def isPrime(n):
list=[2]
if n > 1:
for i in range(2, n+1):
for a in range (2, n):
if i*a != i and i%a != 0 and i%2 != 0:
list.append(i)
break
return "\n".join(map(str, list))`
def main():
n = getNumber(main)
print(isPrime(n))
main()
You've got your logic a bit wrong. Here's what your code is doing:
Examine numbers in increasing order from 2 to the inputted n.
For each number i, check if any number a between 2 and n divides i
If a divides i, add i to the list, and then move to the next i
This isn't going to get you a prime number. In fact, I'm having trouble figuring out what it will give you, but a prime number probably isn't it. Look at this function instead, which will return all the prime numbers less than or equal to the given number - you can compare it to your code to figure out where you went wrong:
def getPrimesLessThanOrEqualTo(n):
if n <= 1: # Anything 1 or less has no primes less than it.
return "" # So, return nothing.
list = [2] # 2 is the lowest prime number <= n
for i in range(3, n+1): # We start at 3 because there's no need to re-check 2
for a in list: # Instead of iterating through everything less than
# i, we can just see if i is divisible by any of
# the primes we've already found
if i % a == 0: # If one of the primes we've found divides i evenly...
break # then go ahead and try the next i
list.append(i) # Now, if we got through that last bit without
# hitting the break statement, we add i to our list
return "\n".join(list) # Finally, return our list of primes <= i
If you wanted to be more efficient, you could even use range(3, n+1, 2) to count by twos - thus avoiding looking at even numbers at all.
You can use a if/else block if your break is never executed by any item in the iterable the else statement will triggered. https://docs.python.org/3/tutorial/controlflow.html 4.4 demonstrates this accomplishing this almost exact task.
n = int(input('Enter number: '))
if n <= 1:
print('No primes')
else:
primes = []
for i in range(2, n +1):
for k in range(2, i):
if not i % k:
break
else:
primes.append(i)
print(*primes)
# Enter number: 50
# 2 3 5 7 11 13 17 19 23 29 31 37 41 43 47
With this code, I only get to test if the number the user entered is prime or not.
How do I add another loop to my original code in order to find all the prime numbers less than or equal to the number the user has entered?
num = int(input("Enter a number: "))
if num > 1:
prime = True
for n in range(2, num):
if (num % n) == 0:
print ("Number", num, "is not prime")
break
else:
print("Number", num, "is prime")
You can'not print both in one loop, you can do one thing add a loop above your current loop and display each number like this :
num = int(input("Enter a number: "))
if num > 1:
prime = True
for n in range(2, num):
if (num % n) == 0:
print ("Number", num, "is not prime")
break
else:
print("Number", num, "is prime")
#your current code ends here
for j in range(2, num + 1):
# prime numbers are greater than 1
for i in range(2, j):
if (j % i) == 0:
break
else:
print(j)
Your code only check the number entered is prime or not , but you questioned about to get prime numbers from 2 to n (n = number entered by user) for this you run below code with the help of flag bit it will little bit easy for you. i hope it will help you.
Try This i run this code It will Surely help you to find your answer it work in python 3.0 or above
num = int(input("Enter The Number"))
if num > 1:
num = num+1
list = []
for j in range (2,num,1):
flag = 0
for i in range (2,int(j/2)+1,1):
if(j%i)== 0:
flag = 1
break
if flag==0:
list.append(j)
print(list)
else:
print("Enter Number Greater Than 1")
Aside from small things (unused boolean variable) your prime test is also super inefficient.
Let's go through this step by step.
First: To test if a number is prime, you don't need to check all integers up to the number for divisors. Actually, going up to sqrt(num) turns out to be sufficient. We can write a one-liner function to find out if a number is prime like so:
from numpy import sqrt
def is_prime(n):
return n > 1 and all(n%i for i in range(2,int(sqrt(n))+1))
range(2,some_num) gives an iterator through all numbers from 2 up to some_num-1and the all() function checks if the statement n%i is true everywhere in that iterator and returns a boolean. If you can guarantee to never pass even numbers you can start the range from 3 (of course with the loss of generality). Even if you don't want to use that function, it's cleaner to separate the functionality into a different function, because in a loop of numbers up to your input you will probably have to check each number for being prime separately anyways.
Second: From here, finding all primes smaller or equal than your input should be pretty easy.
num = int(input("Enter a number:"))
assert num>0, "Please provide a positive integer" # stops with an assertion error if num<=0
prime_lst = [2] if num > 1 else []
for x in range(3,num+1,2):
if is_prime(x):
prime_lst.append(x)
The list prime_lst will contain all your sought after prime numbers. I start the loop from 1 such that I can loop through only the odd numbers, even numbers are divisible by two. So this way none of the numbers will be divisible by two. Unfortunately this requires me to check if the number itself may be 2, which is a prime. By the twin-prime conjecture we can not simplify this range further without knowing about the input.
Finally: If you really want to find the primes in one loop, change your loop to something along the lines of:
prime_lst = [2] if num > 1 else []
for x in range(3,num+1,2): # outer loop
for i in range(3,int(sqrt(x))+1): # inner loop for check if x is prime
if x%i == 0:
break # breaks the inner loop, number is not prime
else:
prime_lst.append(x)
Edit: Just saw that the second answer here has a good explanation (and an even better way) of writing the one-liner for finding out if a number is prime.
The problem is that you need to find the prime number after the number input, or if the number input is prime, return that. It works fine. It's just not working when the input is print(brute_prime(1000)). It returns 1001 not 1009. The full code is this:
def brute_prime(n):
for i in range(2, int(n**(0.5))):
if n % i == 0:
n += 1
else:
return n
As Barmar suggests, you need to restart the loop each time you increment n. Your range also ends earlier than it should, as a range stops just before the second argument.
def brute_prime(n):
while True:
for i in range(2, int(n**(0.5)) + 1):
if n % i == 0:
break
else:
return n
n = n+1
remember 2 is a prime number. again you can just check the division by 2 and skip all the even number division
def brute_prime(n):
while True:
if n==2:return n
elif n%2 ==0 or any(n % i==0 for i in range(3, int(n**(0.5)+1),2)):
n += 1
else:
return n
You're not restarting the for i loop when you discover that a number is not prime and go to the next number. This has two problems: you don't check whether the next number is a multiple of any of the factors that you checked earlier, and you also don't increase the end of the range to int(n ** 0.5) with the new value of n.
def brute_prime(n):
while true:
prime = true
for i in range(2, int(n ** 0.5)+1):
if n % i == 0:
prime = false
break
if prime:
return n
n += 1
break will exit the for loop, and while true: will restart it after n has been incremented.
as mention by Chris Martin the wise solution is define a isPrime function separately and use it to get your desire number.
for example like this
def isPrime(n):
#put here your favorite primality test
from itertools import count
def nextPrime(n):
if isPrime(n):
return n
n += 1 if n%2==0 else 2
for x in count(n,2):
if isPrime(x):
return x
if the given number is not prime, with n += 1 if n%2==0 else 2 it move to the next odd number and with count check every odd number from that point forward.
for isPrime trial division is fine for small numbers, but if you want to use it with bigger numbers I recommend the Miller-Rabin test (deterministic version) or the Baille-PSW test. You can find a python implementation of both version of the Miller test here: http://rosettacode.org/wiki/Miller%E2%80%93Rabin_primality_test#Python
I am trying to put together a simple program which could work out n prime numbers. I would like to do this by using a nested for loop, where one would go through the numbers, and another would divide that number by all of the numbers up to it to see if it would be divisible by anything.
The problem I am having is that in the main for loop, I need to start it at 2, seeing as 1 would mess up the system and I don't want it to be considered a prime. For the loop to have a starting number however, it also needs an ending number which is difficult in this instance as it is hard to generate the largest prime that will be needed prior to the loop working.
Here's the program that I am using right now. Where I have marked X is where I need to somehow put an ending number for the For Loop. I guess it would be much simpler if I let the For Loop be completely open, and simply take out anything that '1' would produce in the loop itself, but this feels like cheating and I want to do it right.
check = 0
limit = int(input("Enter the amount of Prime Numbers"))
for i in range(2,X):
check = 0
if i > 1:
for j in range(2,i):
if (i % j) == 0:
check = 1
if check == 0:
print (i)
Thanks for your help!
You can step through an unlimited amount of numbers using a generator object.
Insert the following somewhere near the top of your code:
def infinite_number_generator(initial_value=2):
""" Generates an infinite amount of numbers """
i = initial_value
while True:
yield i
i += 1
What this does is it creates a function for constructing generator objects that "pause" whenever they reach the yield statement to "yield" whatever value is specified by the yield command, and then continue to execute from the next line beneath the yield statement.
Python's own range function is itself an example of a generator, and is roughly equivalent to (ignoring the step argument and other peculiarities)
def range(start, end):
i = start
while i < end:
yield i
i += 1
So your program would then look like this:
def infinite_number_generator(initial_value=2):
""" Generates an infinite amount of numbers """
i = initial_value
while True:
yield i
i += 1
check = 0
limit = int(input("Enter the amount of Prime Numbers"))
for i in infinite_number_generator():
check = 0
for j in range(2,i):
if (i % j) == 0:
check = 1
if check == 0:
print (i)
if i == limit:
break
I should also point out that the code you provided is buggy - it will never stop printing because there's no checking whether you've found your limit number of primes yet or not.
This should do what you want.
check = 0
limit = int(input("Enter the amount of Prime Numbers"))
counter = 0
i = 2
while counter < limit:
check = 0
if i > 1:
for j in range(2,i):
if (i % j) == 0:
check = 1
if check == 0:
counter += 1
print (i)
i += 1
In your code you start i with 2 and always increment by 1, so the i will always remain greater than 1, therefore the test if i > 1 is useless.
For efficiency you can stop the check at the square of i or i/2 (no divisors in [i/2 + 1, i[ ).
you can update your code as follow:
n = int(input("Enter the amount of Prime Numbers: "))
FoundPrimes = 0
i = 2
while FoundPrimes < n:
isPrime = True
for j in range(2,1 + i//2):
if (i % j) == 0:
isPrime = False
if isPrime:
FoundPrimes += 1
print(i, end = '\t')
i += 1
for homework in an introductory python class, one of the questions is to count the number of even numbers in n. here's my code so far:
def num_even_digits(n):
i=0
count = 0
while i < n:
i+=1
if n%2==0:
count += 1
return count
print(num_even_digits(123456))
Pythonic answer:
def num_even_digits(x):
return len([ y for y in str(x) if int(y) % 2 == 0])
print(num_even_digits(123456))
Disclaimer: I recognized that, for an introductory Python class, my answer may not be appropriate.
you are comparing the whole number every time. you need to convert it to a string and then loop over every number in that string of numbers, cast it back to an integer and see if its remainder is 0
def num_even_digits(numbers):
count = 0
numbers = str(numbers)
for number in numbers:
try:
number = int(number)
except ValueError:
continue
if number % 2 == 0:
count += 1
return count
print(num_even_digits(123456))
if you want to actually loop through every possible number in the range of 0 to your large number you can do this.
def num_even_digits(numbers):
count = 0
for number in range(0, numbers):
if number % 2 == 0:
count += 1
return count
print(num_even_digits(10))
problems with your current function:
def num_even_digits(n): # n is not descriptive, try to make your variable names understandable
i=0
count = 0
while i < n: # looping over every number from 0 to one hundred twenty three thousand four hundred and fifty six.
i+=1
if n%2==0: # n hasn't changed so this is always going to be true
count += 1
return count
print(num_even_digits(123456))