Related
I have this code:
import sys
def random(size=16):
return open(r"C:\Users\ravishankarv\Documents\Python\key.txt").read(size)
def main():
key = random(13)
print(key)
When I try running the script, there are no errors, but nothing appears to happen. I expected it to print some content from the key file, but nothing is printed.
What is wrong? How do I make the code run?
You've not called your main function at all, so the Python interpreter won't call it for you.
Add this as the last line to just have it called at all times:
main()
Or, if you use the commonly seen:
if __name__ == "__main__":
main()
It will make sure your main method is called only if that module is executed as the starting code by the Python interpreter. More about that here: What does if __name__ == "__main__": do?
If you want to know how to write the best possible 'main' function, Guido van Rossum (the creator of Python) wrote about it here.
Python isn't like other languages where it automatically calls the main() function. All you have done is defined your function.
You have to manually call your main function:
main()
Also, you may commonly see this in some code:
if __name__ == '__main__':
main()
There's no such main method in python, what you have to do is:
if __name__ == '__main__':
main()
Something does happen, it just isn't noticeable
Python runs scripts from top to bottom. def is a statement, and it executes when it is encountered, just like any other statement. However, the effect of this is to create the function (and assign it a name), not to call it. Similarly, import is a statement that loads the other module (and makes its code run top to bottom, with its own global-variable context), and assigns it a name.
When the example code runs, therefore, three things happen:
The code for the sys standard library module runs, and then the name sys in our own module's global variables is bound to that module
A function is created from the code for random, and then the name random is bound to that function
A function is created from the code for main, and then the name main is bound to that function
There is nothing to call the functions, so they aren't called. Since they aren't called, the code inside them isn't run - it's only used to create the functions. Since that code doesn't run, the file isn't read and nothing is printed.
There are no "special" function names
Unlike in some other languages, Python does not care that a function is named main, or anything else. It will not be run automatically.
As the Zen of Python says, "Explicit is better than implicit". If we want a function to be called, we have to call it. The only things that run automatically are the things at top level, because those are the instructions we explicitly gave.
The script starts at the top
In many real-world scripts, you may see a line that says if __name__ == '__main__':. This is not "where the script starts". The script runs top to bottom.
Please read What does if __name__ == "__main__": do? to understand the purpose of such an if statement (short version: it makes sure that part of your top-level code is skipped if someone else imports this file as a module). It is not mandatory, and it does not have any kind of special "signalling" purpose to say where the code starts running. It is just a perfectly normal if statement, that is checking a slightly unusual condition. Nothing requires you to use it in a script (aside from wanting to check what it checks), and nothing prevents you from using it more than once. Nothing prevents you from checking whether __name__ is equal to other values, either (it's just... almost certainly useless).
You're not calling the function. Put main() at the bottom of your code.
I have two scripts 1 and 2, I would need these two script to work independently from one another, but I also need script 2 to be able to use the function in script 1 if needed. I tried to automate as much as possible, so each script has a number of variables inside already defined.
Here is an oversimplified example of the scrips that I am talking about.
Script 1:
def plustwo(n):
out = n + 2
print(out)
m=3
plustwo(m)
Result:
5
Script 2:
from file import plustwo
z=5
plustwo(z)
Result:
5
7
As you can see, when I import the function from script 1, even if I use from file import plustwo, also the variable is imported, this causes script 2 to return two results, one with variable m (5) and another with variable z (7).
Do I necessarily need to create a third script, identical to script 2 but without the m variable? Is there a way to exclude such variable from the import? (I just want the function from script 2, so that I can use script 1 with the variables it already has.)
In script 1, you can add if __name__ == '__main__':, so that it only executes
m=3
plustwo(m)
if the program is run directly from script1.py.
In the end, you only need to modify script 1 a little bit:
def plustwo(n):
out = n + 2
print(out)
if __name__ == '__main__':
m=3
plustwo(m)
No, it is not.
An import statement will always execute the whole target module the first time it runs. Even when the import is written to cherry pick just a few functions and names from the target file, the file is still executed from the first to last line - this is the way the language works.
The "module object" created in this execution (basically a namespace with all the functions, classes and variables defined globally in the module), is them made available on the sys.modules dictionary. On a second import statement referencing the same file, it will not run again: the cached version is used to pick any function or variables from it.
The practice for when a module file has direct side-effects on itself, and it still desirable that parts of it should be importable, is to put the code that you don't want to execute upon importing in a block that only runs if the automatic variable __name__ contains the string "__main__". Python does that so a module can "know" if a module is running as the main program, or has been imported as part of a greater system.
The idiom for this is ubiquous in Python projects and usually look like:
...
if __name__ == "__main__":
# this block only runs when the coded is executed as the main program
m = 3
plustwo(m)
(This comes, for obvious reasons, at the end of the file, after the function has been defined)
Otherwise, the only possible workaround for that would be to read the module file as a text file, parse and re-generate another source file dynamically, containing only the lines one is interested in, which would then be imported. And even so, the functions or classes imported in this way would not possibly address any other function, class or variable in the same module, of course.
I have a Python program I'm building that can be run in either of 2 ways: the first is to call python main.py which prompts the user for input in a friendly manner and then runs the user input through the program. The other way is to call python batch.py -file- which will pass over all the friendly input gathering and run an entire file's worth of input through the program in a single go.
The problem is that when I run batch.py, it imports some variables/methods/etc from main.py, and when it runs this code:
import main
at the first line of the program, it immediately errors because it tries to run the code in main.py.
How can I stop Python from running the code contained in the main module which I'm importing?
Because this is just how Python works - keywords such as class and def are not declarations. Instead, they are real live statements which are executed. If they were not executed your module would be empty.
The idiomatic approach is:
# stuff to run always here such as class/def
def main():
pass
if __name__ == "__main__":
# stuff only to run when not called via 'import' here
main()
It does require source control over the module being imported, however.
Due to the way Python works, it is necessary for it to run your modules when it imports them.
To prevent code in the module from being executed when imported, but only when run directly, you can guard it with this if:
if __name__ == "__main__":
# this won't be run when imported
You may want to put this code in a main() method, so that you can either execute the file directly, or import the module and call the main(). For example, assume this is in the file foo.py.
def main():
print "Hello World"
if __name__ == "__main__":
main()
This program can be run either by going python foo.py, or from another Python script:
import foo
...
foo.main()
Use the if __name__ == '__main__' idiom -- __name__ is a special variable whose value is '__main__' if the module is being run as a script, and the module name if it's imported. So you'd do something like
# imports
# class/function definitions
if __name__ == '__main__':
# code here will only run when you invoke 'python main.py'
Unfortunately, you don't. That is part of how the import syntax works and it is important that it does so -- remember def is actually something executed, if Python did not execute the import, you'd be, well, stuck without functions.
Since you probably have access to the file, though, you might be able to look and see what causes the error. It might be possible to modify your environment to prevent the error from happening.
Put the code inside a function and it won't run until you call the function. You should have a main function in your main.py. with the statement:
if __name__ == '__main__':
main()
Then, if you call python main.py the main() function will run. If you import main.py, it will not. Also, you should probably rename main.py to something else for clarity's sake.
There was a Python enhancement proposal PEP 299 which aimed to replace if __name__ == '__main__': idiom with def __main__:, but it was rejected. It's still a good read to know what to keep in mind when using if __name__ = '__main__':.
You may write your "main.py" like this:
#!/usr/bin/env python
__all__=["somevar", "do_something"]
somevar=""
def do_something():
pass #blahblah
if __name__=="__main__":
do_something()
I did a simple test:
#test.py
x = 1
print("1, has it been executed?")
def t1():
print("hello")
print("2, has it been executed?")
def t2():
print("world")
print("3, has it been executed?")
def main():
print("Hello World")
print("4, has it been executed?")
print("5, has it been executed?")
print(x)
# while True:
# t2()
if x == 1:
print("6, has it been executed?")
#test2.py
import test
When executing or running test2.py, the running result:
1, has it been executed?
5, has it been executed?
1
6, has it been executed?
Conclusion: When the imported module does not add if __name__=="__main__":, the current module is run, The code in the imported module that is not in the function is executed sequentially, and the code in the function is not executed when it is not called.
in addition：
def main():
# Put all your code you need to execute directly when this script run directly.
pass
if __name__ == '__main__':
main()
else:
# Put functions you need to be executed only whenever imported
A minor error that could happen (at least it happened to me), especially when distributing python scripts/functions that carry out a complete analysis, was to call the function directly at the end of the function .py file.
The only things a user needed to modify were the input files and parameters.
Doing so when you import you'll get the function running immediately. For proper behavior, you simply need to remove the inside call to the function and reserve it for the real calling file/function/portion of code
Another option is to use a binary environment variable, e.g. lets call it 'run_code'. If run_code = 0 (False) structure main.py to bypass the code (but the temporarily bypassed function will still be imported as a module). Later when you are ready to use the imported function (now a module) set the environment variable run_code = 1 (True). Use the os.environ command to set and retrieve the binary variable, but be sure to convert it to an integer when retrieving (or restructure the if statement to read a string value),
in main.py:
import os
#set environment variable to 0 (False):
os.environ['run_code'] = '0'
def binary_module():
#retrieve environment variable, convert to integer
run_code_val = int(os.environ['run_code'] )
if run_code_val == 0:
print('nope. not doing it.')
if run_code_val == 1:
print('executing code...')
# [do something]
...in whatever script is loading main.py:
import os,main
main.binary_module()
OUTPUT: nope. not doing it.
# now flip the on switch!
os.environ['run_code'] = '1'
main.binary_module()
OUTPUT: executing code...
*Note: The above code presumes main.py and whatever script imports it exist in the same directory.
Although you cannot use import without running the code; there is quite a swift way in which you can input your variables; by using numpy.savez, which stores variables as numpy arrays in a .npz file. Afterwards you can load the variables using numpy.load.
See a full description in the scipy documentation
Please note this is only the case for variables and arrays of variable, and not for methods, etc.
Try just importing the functions needed from main.py? So,
from main import SomeFunction
It could be that you've named a function in batch.py the same as one in main.py, and when you import main.py the program runs the main.py function instead of the batch.py function; doing the above should fix that. I hope.
I have a Python program I'm building that can be run in either of 2 ways: the first is to call python main.py which prompts the user for input in a friendly manner and then runs the user input through the program. The other way is to call python batch.py -file- which will pass over all the friendly input gathering and run an entire file's worth of input through the program in a single go.
The problem is that when I run batch.py, it imports some variables/methods/etc from main.py, and when it runs this code:
import main
at the first line of the program, it immediately errors because it tries to run the code in main.py.
How can I stop Python from running the code contained in the main module which I'm importing?
Because this is just how Python works - keywords such as class and def are not declarations. Instead, they are real live statements which are executed. If they were not executed your module would be empty.
The idiomatic approach is:
# stuff to run always here such as class/def
def main():
pass
if __name__ == "__main__":
# stuff only to run when not called via 'import' here
main()
It does require source control over the module being imported, however.
Due to the way Python works, it is necessary for it to run your modules when it imports them.
To prevent code in the module from being executed when imported, but only when run directly, you can guard it with this if:
if __name__ == "__main__":
# this won't be run when imported
You may want to put this code in a main() method, so that you can either execute the file directly, or import the module and call the main(). For example, assume this is in the file foo.py.
def main():
print "Hello World"
if __name__ == "__main__":
main()
This program can be run either by going python foo.py, or from another Python script:
import foo
...
foo.main()
Use the if __name__ == '__main__' idiom -- __name__ is a special variable whose value is '__main__' if the module is being run as a script, and the module name if it's imported. So you'd do something like
# imports
# class/function definitions
if __name__ == '__main__':
# code here will only run when you invoke 'python main.py'
Unfortunately, you don't. That is part of how the import syntax works and it is important that it does so -- remember def is actually something executed, if Python did not execute the import, you'd be, well, stuck without functions.
Since you probably have access to the file, though, you might be able to look and see what causes the error. It might be possible to modify your environment to prevent the error from happening.
Put the code inside a function and it won't run until you call the function. You should have a main function in your main.py. with the statement:
if __name__ == '__main__':
main()
Then, if you call python main.py the main() function will run. If you import main.py, it will not. Also, you should probably rename main.py to something else for clarity's sake.
There was a Python enhancement proposal PEP 299 which aimed to replace if __name__ == '__main__': idiom with def __main__:, but it was rejected. It's still a good read to know what to keep in mind when using if __name__ = '__main__':.
You may write your "main.py" like this:
#!/usr/bin/env python
__all__=["somevar", "do_something"]
somevar=""
def do_something():
pass #blahblah
if __name__=="__main__":
do_something()
I did a simple test:
#test.py
x = 1
print("1, has it been executed?")
def t1():
print("hello")
print("2, has it been executed?")
def t2():
print("world")
print("3, has it been executed?")
def main():
print("Hello World")
print("4, has it been executed?")
print("5, has it been executed?")
print(x)
# while True:
# t2()
if x == 1:
print("6, has it been executed?")
#test2.py
import test
When executing or running test2.py, the running result:
1, has it been executed?
5, has it been executed?
1
6, has it been executed?
Conclusion: When the imported module does not add if __name__=="__main__":, the current module is run, The code in the imported module that is not in the function is executed sequentially, and the code in the function is not executed when it is not called.
in addition：
def main():
# Put all your code you need to execute directly when this script run directly.
pass
if __name__ == '__main__':
main()
else:
# Put functions you need to be executed only whenever imported
A minor error that could happen (at least it happened to me), especially when distributing python scripts/functions that carry out a complete analysis, was to call the function directly at the end of the function .py file.
The only things a user needed to modify were the input files and parameters.
Doing so when you import you'll get the function running immediately. For proper behavior, you simply need to remove the inside call to the function and reserve it for the real calling file/function/portion of code
Another option is to use a binary environment variable, e.g. lets call it 'run_code'. If run_code = 0 (False) structure main.py to bypass the code (but the temporarily bypassed function will still be imported as a module). Later when you are ready to use the imported function (now a module) set the environment variable run_code = 1 (True). Use the os.environ command to set and retrieve the binary variable, but be sure to convert it to an integer when retrieving (or restructure the if statement to read a string value),
in main.py:
import os
#set environment variable to 0 (False):
os.environ['run_code'] = '0'
def binary_module():
#retrieve environment variable, convert to integer
run_code_val = int(os.environ['run_code'] )
if run_code_val == 0:
print('nope. not doing it.')
if run_code_val == 1:
print('executing code...')
# [do something]
...in whatever script is loading main.py:
import os,main
main.binary_module()
OUTPUT: nope. not doing it.
# now flip the on switch!
os.environ['run_code'] = '1'
main.binary_module()
OUTPUT: executing code...
*Note: The above code presumes main.py and whatever script imports it exist in the same directory.
Although you cannot use import without running the code; there is quite a swift way in which you can input your variables; by using numpy.savez, which stores variables as numpy arrays in a .npz file. Afterwards you can load the variables using numpy.load.
See a full description in the scipy documentation
Please note this is only the case for variables and arrays of variable, and not for methods, etc.
Try just importing the functions needed from main.py? So,
from main import SomeFunction
It could be that you've named a function in batch.py the same as one in main.py, and when you import main.py the program runs the main.py function instead of the batch.py function; doing the above should fix that. I hope.
Should the function name main() always be empty and have arguments called within the function itself or is it acceptable to have them as inputs to the function e.g main(arg1, arg2, arg3)?
I know it works but I'm wondering if it is poor programming practice. Apologies if this is a duplicate but I couldn't see the question specifically answered for Python.
In most other programming languages, you'd either have zero parameters or two parameters:
int main(char *argv[], int argc)
To denote the arguments passed through to the parameter. However, in Python these are accessed through the sys module:
import sys
def main():
print(sys.argv, len(sys.argv))
But then you could extend this so that you pass through argv and argc into your python function, similar to other languages yes:
import sys
def main(argv, arc):
print(argv, arc)
if __name__ == '__main__':
main(sys.argv, len(sys.argv))
But let's forget about argv/argc for now - why would you want to pass something through to main. You create something outside of main and want to pass it through to main. And this can happen in two instances:
You're calling main multiple times from other functions.
You've created variables outside main that you want to pass through.
Point number 1 is definitely bad practice. main should be unique and called only once at the beginning of your program. If you have the need to call it multiple times, then the code inside main doesn't belong inside main. Split it up.
Point number 2 may seem like it makes sense, but then you do it in practise:
def main(a, b):
print(a, b)
if __name__ == '__main__':
x = 4
y = 5
main(x, y)
But then aren't x and y global variables? And good practice would assume that these are at the top of your file (and multiple other properties - they're constant, etc), and that you wouldn't need to pass these through as arguments.
By following the pattern:
def main():
...stuff...
if __name__ == '__main__':
main()
It allows your script to both to be run directly, and if packaged using setup tools, to have an executable script generated automatically when the package is installed by specifying main as an entry point.
See: https://setuptools.readthedocs.io/en/latest/setuptools.html#automatic-script-creation
You would add to setup.py something like:
entry_points={
'console_scripts': [
'my_script = my_module:main'
]
}
And then when you build a package, people can install it in their virtual environment, and immediately get a script called my_script on their path.
Automatic script creation like this requires a function that takes no required arguments.
It's a good idea to allow you script to be imported and expose it's functionality both for code reuse, and also for testing. I would recommend something line this pattern:
import argparse
def parse_args():
parser = argparse.ArgumentParser()
#
# ... configure command line arguments ...
#
return parser.parse_args()
def do_stuff(args):
#
# ... main functionality goes in here ...
#
def main():
args = parse_args()
do_stuff(args)
if __name__ == '__main__':
main()
This allows you to run your script directly, have an automatically generated script that behaves the same way, and also import the script and call do_stuff to re-use or test the actual functionality.
This blog post was mentioned in the comments: https://www.artima.com/weblogs/viewpost.jsp?thread=4829 which uses a default argument on main to allow dependency injection for testing, however, this is a very old blog post; the getopt library has been superseded twice since then. This pattern is superior and still allows dependency injection.
I would definitely prefer to see main take arguments rather than accessing sys.argv directly.
This makes the reuse of the main function by other Python modules much easier.
import sys
def main(arg):
...
if __name__ == "__main__":
main(sys.argv[1])
Now if I want to execute this module as a script from another module I can just write (in my other module).
from main_script import main
main("use this argument")
If main uses sys.argv this is tougher.