From what I can see, boxplot() method expects a sequence of raw values (numbers) as input, from which it then computes percentiles to draw the boxplot(s).
I would like to have a method by which I could pass in the percentiles and get the corresponding boxplot.
For example:
Assume that I have run several benchmarks and for each benchmark I've measured latencies ( floating point values ). Now additionally, I have precomputed the percentiles for these values.
Hence for each benchmark, I have the 25th, 50th, 75th percentile along with the min and max.
Now given these data, I would like to draw the box plots for the benchmarks.
As of 2020, there is a better method than the one in the accepted answer.
The matplotlib.axes.Axes class provides a bxp method, which can be used to draw the boxes and whiskers based on the percentile values. Raw data is only needed for the outliers, and that is optional.
Example:
import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
fig, ax = plt.subplots()
boxes = [
{
'label' : "Male height",
'whislo': 162.6, # Bottom whisker position
'q1' : 170.2, # First quartile (25th percentile)
'med' : 175.7, # Median (50th percentile)
'q3' : 180.4, # Third quartile (75th percentile)
'whishi': 187.8, # Top whisker position
'fliers': [] # Outliers
}
]
ax.bxp(boxes, showfliers=False)
ax.set_ylabel("cm")
plt.savefig("boxplot.png")
plt.close()
This produces the following image:
To draw the box plot using just the percentile values and the outliers ( if any ) I made a customized_box_plot function that basically modifies attributes in a basic box plot ( generated from a tiny sample data ) to make it fit according to your percentile values.
The customized_box_plot function
def customized_box_plot(percentiles, axes, redraw = True, *args, **kwargs):
"""
Generates a customized boxplot based on the given percentile values
"""
box_plot = axes.boxplot([[-9, -4, 2, 4, 9],]*n_box, *args, **kwargs)
# Creates len(percentiles) no of box plots
min_y, max_y = float('inf'), -float('inf')
for box_no, (q1_start,
q2_start,
q3_start,
q4_start,
q4_end,
fliers_xy) in enumerate(percentiles):
# Lower cap
box_plot['caps'][2*box_no].set_ydata([q1_start, q1_start])
# xdata is determined by the width of the box plot
# Lower whiskers
box_plot['whiskers'][2*box_no].set_ydata([q1_start, q2_start])
# Higher cap
box_plot['caps'][2*box_no + 1].set_ydata([q4_end, q4_end])
# Higher whiskers
box_plot['whiskers'][2*box_no + 1].set_ydata([q4_start, q4_end])
# Box
box_plot['boxes'][box_no].set_ydata([q2_start,
q2_start,
q4_start,
q4_start,
q2_start])
# Median
box_plot['medians'][box_no].set_ydata([q3_start, q3_start])
# Outliers
if fliers_xy is not None and len(fliers_xy[0]) != 0:
# If outliers exist
box_plot['fliers'][box_no].set(xdata = fliers_xy[0],
ydata = fliers_xy[1])
min_y = min(q1_start, min_y, fliers_xy[1].min())
max_y = max(q4_end, max_y, fliers_xy[1].max())
else:
min_y = min(q1_start, min_y)
max_y = max(q4_end, max_y)
# The y axis is rescaled to fit the new box plot completely with 10%
# of the maximum value at both ends
axes.set_ylim([min_y*1.1, max_y*1.1])
# If redraw is set to true, the canvas is updated.
if redraw:
ax.figure.canvas.draw()
return box_plot
USAGE
Using inverse logic ( code at the very end ) I extracted the percentile values from this example
>>> percentiles
(-1.0597368367634488, 0.3977683984966961, 1.0298955252405229, 1.6693981537742526, 3.4951447843464449)
(-0.90494930553559483, 0.36916539612108634, 1.0303658700697103, 1.6874542731392828, 3.4951447843464449)
(0.13744105279440233, 1.3300645202649739, 2.6131540656339483, 4.8763411136047647, 9.5751914834437937)
(0.22786243898199182, 1.4120860286080519, 2.637650402506837, 4.9067126578493259, 9.4660357513550899)
(0.0064696168078617741, 0.30586770128093388, 0.70774153557312702, 1.5241965711101928, 3.3092932063051976)
(0.007009744579241136, 0.28627373934008982, 0.66039691869500572, 1.4772725266672091, 3.221716765477217)
(-2.2621660374110544, 5.1901313713883352, 7.7178532139979357, 11.277744848353247, 20.155971739152388)
(-2.2621660374110544, 5.1884411864079532, 7.3357079047721054, 10.792299385806913, 18.842012119715388)
(2.5417888074435702, 5.885996170695587, 7.7271286220368598, 8.9207423361593179, 10.846938621419374)
(2.5971767318505856, 5.753551925927133, 7.6569980004033464, 8.8161056254143233, 10.846938621419374)
Note that to keep this short I haven't shown the outliers vectors which will be the 6th element of each of the percentile array.
Also note that all usual additional kwargs / args can be used since they are simply passed to the boxplot method inside it :
>>> fig, ax = plt.subplots()
>>> b = customized_box_plot(percentiles, ax, redraw=True, notch=0, sym='+', vert=1, whis=1.5)
>>> plt.show()
EXPLANATION
The boxplot method returns a dictionary mapping the components of the boxplot to the individual matplotlib.lines.Line2D instances that were created.
Quoting from the matplotlib.pyplot.boxplot documentation :
That dictionary has the following keys (assuming vertical boxplots):
boxes: the main body of the boxplot showing the quartiles and the median’s confidence intervals if enabled.
medians: horizonal lines at the median of each box.
whiskers: the vertical lines extending to the most extreme, n-outlier data points. caps: the horizontal lines at the ends of the whiskers.
fliers: points representing data that extend beyond the whiskers (outliers).
means: points or lines representing the means.
For example observe the boxplot of a tiny sample data of [-9, -4, 2, 4, 9]
>>> b = ax.boxplot([[-9, -4, 2, 4, 9],])
>>> b
{'boxes': [<matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fe1f5b21350>],
'caps': [<matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fe1f54d4e50>,
<matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fe1f54d0e50>],
'fliers': [<matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fe1f5b317d0>],
'means': [],
'medians': [<matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fe1f63549d0>],
'whiskers': [<matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fe1f5b22e10>,
<matplotlib.lines.Line2D at 0x7fe20c54a510>]}
>>> plt.show()
The matplotlib.lines.Line2D objects have two methods that I'll be using in my function extensively. set_xdata ( or set_ydata ) and get_xdata ( or get_ydata ).
Using these methods we can alter the position of the constituent lines of the base box plot to conform to your percentile values ( which is what the customized_box_plot function does ). After altering the constituent lines' position, you can redraw the canvas using figure.canvas.draw()
Summarizing the mappings from percentile to the coordinates of the various Line2D objects.
The Y Coordinates :
The max ( q4_end - end of 4th quartile ) corresponds to the top most cap Line2D object.
The min ( q1_start - start of the 1st quartile ) corresponds to the lowermost most cap Line2D object.
The median corresponds to the ( q3_start ) median Line2D object.
The 2 whiskers lie between the ends of the boxes and extreme caps ( q1_start and q2_start - lower whisker; q4_start and q4_end - upper whisker )
The box is actually an interesting n shaped line bounded by a cap at the lower portion. The extremes of the n shaped line correspond to the q2_start and the q4_start.
The X Coordinates :
The Central x coordinates ( for multiple box plots are usually 1, 2, 3... )
The library automatically calculates the bounding x coordinates based on the width specified.
INVERSE FUNCTION TO RETRIEVE THE PERCENTILES FROM THE boxplot DICT:
def get_percentiles_from_box_plots(bp):
percentiles = []
for i in range(len(bp['boxes'])):
percentiles.append((bp['caps'][2*i].get_ydata()[0],
bp['boxes'][i].get_ydata()[0],
bp['medians'][i].get_ydata()[0],
bp['boxes'][i].get_ydata()[2],
bp['caps'][2*i + 1].get_ydata()[0],
(bp['fliers'][i].get_xdata(),
bp['fliers'][i].get_ydata())))
return percentiles
NOTE:
The reason why I did not make a completely custom boxplot method is because, there are many features offered by the inbuilt box plot that cannot be fully reproduced.
Also excuse me if I may have unnecessarily explained something that may have been too obvious.
Here is an updated version of this useful routine. Setting the vertices directly appears to work for both filled boxes (patchArtist=True) and unfilled ones.
def customized_box_plot(percentiles, axes, redraw = True, *args, **kwargs):
"""
Generates a customized boxplot based on the given percentile values
"""
n_box = len(percentiles)
box_plot = axes.boxplot([[-9, -4, 2, 4, 9],]*n_box, *args, **kwargs)
# Creates len(percentiles) no of box plots
min_y, max_y = float('inf'), -float('inf')
for box_no, pdata in enumerate(percentiles):
if len(pdata) == 6:
(q1_start, q2_start, q3_start, q4_start, q4_end, fliers_xy) = pdata
elif len(pdata) == 5:
(q1_start, q2_start, q3_start, q4_start, q4_end) = pdata
fliers_xy = None
else:
raise ValueError("Percentile arrays for customized_box_plot must have either 5 or 6 values")
# Lower cap
box_plot['caps'][2*box_no].set_ydata([q1_start, q1_start])
# xdata is determined by the width of the box plot
# Lower whiskers
box_plot['whiskers'][2*box_no].set_ydata([q1_start, q2_start])
# Higher cap
box_plot['caps'][2*box_no + 1].set_ydata([q4_end, q4_end])
# Higher whiskers
box_plot['whiskers'][2*box_no + 1].set_ydata([q4_start, q4_end])
# Box
path = box_plot['boxes'][box_no].get_path()
path.vertices[0][1] = q2_start
path.vertices[1][1] = q2_start
path.vertices[2][1] = q4_start
path.vertices[3][1] = q4_start
path.vertices[4][1] = q2_start
# Median
box_plot['medians'][box_no].set_ydata([q3_start, q3_start])
# Outliers
if fliers_xy is not None and len(fliers_xy[0]) != 0:
# If outliers exist
box_plot['fliers'][box_no].set(xdata = fliers_xy[0],
ydata = fliers_xy[1])
min_y = min(q1_start, min_y, fliers_xy[1].min())
max_y = max(q4_end, max_y, fliers_xy[1].max())
else:
min_y = min(q1_start, min_y)
max_y = max(q4_end, max_y)
# The y axis is rescaled to fit the new box plot completely with 10%
# of the maximum value at both ends
axes.set_ylim([min_y*1.1, max_y*1.1])
# If redraw is set to true, the canvas is updated.
if redraw:
ax.figure.canvas.draw()
return box_plot
Here is a bottom-up approach where the box_plot is build up using matplotlib's vline, Rectangle, and normal plot functions
def boxplot(df, ax=None, box_width=0.2, whisker_size=20, mean_size=10, median_size = 10 , line_width=1.5, xoffset=0,
color=0):
"""Plots a boxplot from existing percentiles.
Parameters
----------
df: pandas DataFrame
ax: pandas AxesSubplot
if to plot on en existing axes
box_width: float
whisker_size: float
size of the bar at the end of each whisker
mean_size: float
size of the mean symbol
color: int or rgb(list)
If int particular color of property cycler is taken. Example of rgb: [1,0,0] (red)
Returns
-------
f, a, boxes, vlines, whisker_tips, mean, median
"""
if type(color) == int:
color = plt.rcParams['axes.prop_cycle'].by_key()['color'][color]
if ax:
a = ax
f = a.get_figure()
else:
f, a = plt.subplots()
boxes = []
vlines = []
xn = []
for row in df.iterrows():
x = row[0] + xoffset
xn.append(x)
# box
y = row[1][25]
height = row[1][75] - row[1][25]
box = plt.Rectangle((x - box_width / 2, y), box_width, height)
a.add_patch(box)
boxes.append(box)
# whiskers
y = (row[1][95] + row[1][5]) / 2
vl = a.vlines(x, row[1][5], row[1][95])
vlines.append(vl)
for b in boxes:
b.set_linewidth(line_width)
b.set_facecolor([1, 1, 1, 1])
b.set_edgecolor(color)
b.set_zorder(2)
for vl in vlines:
vl.set_color(color)
vl.set_linewidth(line_width)
vl.set_zorder(1)
whisker_tips = []
if whisker_size:
g, = a.plot(xn, df[5], ls='')
whisker_tips.append(g)
g, = a.plot(xn, df[95], ls='')
whisker_tips.append(g)
for wt in whisker_tips:
wt.set_markeredgewidth(line_width)
wt.set_color(color)
wt.set_markersize(whisker_size)
wt.set_marker('_')
mean = None
if mean_size:
g, = a.plot(xn, df['mean'], ls='')
g.set_marker('o')
g.set_markersize(mean_size)
g.set_zorder(20)
g.set_markerfacecolor('None')
g.set_markeredgewidth(line_width)
g.set_markeredgecolor(color)
mean = g
median = None
if median_size:
g, = a.plot(xn, df['median'], ls='')
g.set_marker('_')
g.set_markersize(median_size)
g.set_zorder(20)
g.set_markeredgewidth(line_width)
g.set_markeredgecolor(color)
median = g
a.set_ylim(np.nanmin(df), np.nanmax(df))
return f, a, boxes, vlines, whisker_tips, mean, median
This is how it looks in action:
import numpy as np
import pandas as pd
import matplotlib.pylab as plt
nopts = 12
df = pd.DataFrame()
df['mean'] = np.random.random(nopts) + 7
df['median'] = np.random.random(nopts) + 7
df[5] = np.random.random(nopts) + 4
df[25] = np.random.random(nopts) + 6
df[75] = np.random.random(nopts) + 8
df[95] = np.random.random(nopts) + 10
out = boxplot(df)
I am trying to interpolate a curve to a set of (x,y) points using SciPy's interpolate.splprep method, using the procedure followed in this StackOverflow answer. My code (with the data) is given below. Please excuse me for using this large dataset, as the code works perfectly fine on a different dataset. Kindly scroll to the bottom to see the implemetation.
#!/usr/bin/env python3
import numpy as np
import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
from scipy import interpolate
# -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Data
xp=np.array([ -1.19824526e-01, -1.19795807e-01, -1.22298912e-01,
-1.24784611e-01, -1.27233423e-01, -1.27048456e-01,
-1.29424259e-01, -1.31781573e-01, -1.34102825e-01,
-1.36386619e-01, -1.41324999e-01, -1.43569618e-01,
-1.48471481e-01, -1.53300646e-01, -1.55387133e-01,
-1.57436481e-01, -1.53938796e-01, -1.58562951e-01,
-1.53139517e-01, -1.50456275e-01, -1.49637920e-01,
-1.48774455e-01, -1.47843528e-01, -1.44278335e-01,
-1.43299274e-01, -1.39716798e-01, -1.36111285e-01,
-1.32534352e-01, -1.28982866e-01, -1.25433151e-01,
-1.21912263e-01, -1.16106245e-01, -1.12701128e-01,
-1.09303316e-01, -1.05947571e-01, -1.00467194e-01,
-9.72083398e-02, -9.39822094e-02, -9.08033710e-02,
-8.96420533e-02, -8.65053261e-02, -8.34162875e-02,
-8.03788778e-02, -7.73929193e-02, -7.62032638e-02,
-7.32655732e-02, -7.03760465e-02, -6.91826390e-02,
-6.63378816e-02, -6.35537275e-02, -6.08302060e-02,
-5.96426925e-02, -5.69864087e-02, -5.43931715e-02,
-5.18641746e-02, -4.93958173e-02, -4.82415854e-02,
-4.58486281e-02, -4.35196817e-02, -4.01162919e-02,
-3.79466513e-02, -3.48161871e-02, -3.18596693e-02,
-2.90650417e-02, -2.64251761e-02, -2.31429101e-02,
-1.94312163e-02, -1.73997964e-02, -1.55068323e-02,
-1.43163160e-02, -1.31800087e-02, -1.20987991e-02,
-1.10708190e-02, -1.05380016e-02, -9.58116017e-03,
-9.06399242e-03, -8.54450012e-03, -7.67847396e-03,
-7.17608354e-03, -6.67181154e-03, -5.89474349e-03,
-5.40878144e-03, -4.92121197e-03, -4.43202070e-03,
-3.94148294e-03, -3.44986011e-03, -2.82410814e-03,
-2.35269319e-03, -1.88058008e-03, -1.47393691e-03,
-9.78376399e-04, -4.82633521e-04, 1.33099164e-05,
5.09212801e-04, 1.05098855e-03, 1.56929991e-03,
2.08706303e-03, 2.72055571e-03, 3.26012954e-03,
3.79870854e-03, 4.33573131e-03, 4.87172652e-03,
5.40640816e-03, 5.93914581e-03, 6.47004490e-03,
6.99921852e-03, 7.52610639e-03, 7.70592714e-03,
8.20559501e-03, 8.70268809e-03, 9.19766855e-03,
9.68963219e-03, 1.01781695e-02, 1.01960805e-02,
1.06577199e-02, 1.11156340e-02, 1.15703286e-02,
1.20215921e-02, 1.24693015e-02, 1.29129042e-02,
1.33526781e-02, 1.37884367e-02, 1.42204360e-02,
1.46473802e-02, 1.50699789e-02, 1.54884533e-02,
1.59020551e-02, 1.63103362e-02, 8.12110387e-02,
7.80794051e-02, 1.67140103e-02, 8.31537241e-02,
7.99472912e-02, 7.99472912e-02, 7.67983984e-02,
1.71128723e-02, 8.50656342e-02, 8.17851028e-02,
7.85638577e-02, 7.53861405e-02, 1.75061328e-02,
8.19411806e-02, 7.38391281e-02, 1.78939640e-02,
8.70866930e-02, 8.36940292e-02, 8.03586974e-02,
7.70534244e-02, 7.70534244e-02, 7.38013540e-02,
7.38013540e-02, 7.06147796e-02, 1.82766038e-02,
8.54279559e-02, 8.20231372e-02, 7.53294330e-02,
7.20765174e-02, 1.86539411e-02, 8.36524496e-02,
7.85095832e-02, 7.51592888e-02, 7.18792721e-02,
1.90250409e-02, 7.82997201e-02, 7.49183992e-02,
7.49183992e-02, 7.16144248e-02, 7.16144248e-02,
6.83771846e-02, 1.93904576e-02, 7.46192919e-02,
7.12865685e-02, 7.12865685e-02, 6.80175748e-02,
1.97501330e-02, 7.42568965e-02, 7.08996495e-02,
7.08996495e-02, 6.75887344e-02, 2.01042729e-02,
7.38173451e-02, 6.70923613e-02, 2.13903228e-02,
7.50479910e-02, 6.82108239e-02, 5.69753762e-02,
5.24303656e-02, 5.24303656e-02, 4.52683211e-02,
4.52683211e-02, 4.25493203e-02, 2.17470907e-02,
7.45062992e-02, 6.76173090e-02, 6.76173090e-02,
6.42925100e-02, 6.42925100e-02, 5.94649095e-02,
5.94649095e-02, 3.92303424e-02, 2.20977481e-02,
7.21341379e-02, 3.72338037e-02, 2.24415025e-02,
7.14448972e-02, 3.40025442e-02, 2.27777176e-02,
7.07064856e-02, 3.57533680e-02, 2.41421550e-02,
6.81719132e-02, 3.62534788e-02, 2.44798556e-02,
6.56110398e-02, 3.80586628e-02, 3.29287629e-02,
2.93070471e-02, 2.48093588e-02, 6.13326924e-02,
3.85518913e-02, 3.46206958e-02, 2.85091877e-02,
2.51312268e-02, 5.38330011e-02, 3.76841669e-02,
3.50540735e-02, 2.77018960e-02, 2.65615352e-02,
5.28838088e-02, 3.81396763e-02, 3.54777506e-02,
2.80364970e-02, 2.68822682e-02, 5.03377702e-02,
3.85814254e-02, 3.58887890e-02, 4.93316503e-02,
4.04098395e-02, 3.62892096e-02, 4.67615526e-02,
4.22828625e-02, 3.80435955e-02, 3.84376145e-02,
4.02332775e-02, 4.06156847e-02, 4.24553741e-02,
4.43352031e-02, 4.47040511e-02, 4.66233682e-02,
4.69790035e-02, 4.89341212e-02, 5.09256192e-02,
5.12584867e-02, 5.32790231e-02, 5.35890744e-02,
5.38831411e-02, 5.41625645e-02, 5.44267004e-02,
5.46700348e-02, 5.48984863e-02, 5.51117932e-02,
5.53082440e-02, 5.54849716e-02, 5.56464539e-02,
5.57928396e-02, 5.59201893e-02, 5.60294455e-02,
5.61233441e-02, 5.62020138e-02, 5.62604489e-02,
5.63017253e-02, 5.63275468e-02, 5.63341408e-02,
5.63226424e-02, 5.62957310e-02, 5.62533699e-02,
5.61937444e-02, 5.61140110e-02, 5.60191106e-02,
5.59087917e-02, 5.57801898e-02, 5.56328560e-02,
5.54704141e-02, 5.70775198e-02, 5.68728844e-02,
5.66515897e-02, 5.64149230e-02, 5.61622287e-02,
5.76630266e-02, 5.73643873e-02, 5.70502787e-02,
5.67190716e-02, 5.63668473e-02, 5.59997391e-02,
5.73489998e-02, 5.69355151e-02, 5.65029189e-02,
5.77751241e-02, 5.72977910e-02, 5.67990710e-02,
5.79863269e-02, 5.74393835e-02, 5.68773454e-02,
5.62926261e-02, 5.56922722e-02, 5.50771272e-02,
5.44454686e-02, 5.37935810e-02, 5.31273003e-02,
5.24468411e-02, 5.17483760e-02, 5.10330229e-02,
5.03036776e-02, 4.95607328e-02, 4.87997085e-02,
4.80238054e-02, 4.72347342e-02, 4.64331616e-02,
4.56132865e-02, 4.47805574e-02, 4.39358955e-02,
4.30782240e-02, 4.22044750e-02, 4.01052073e-02,
3.92354976e-02, 3.83523540e-02, 3.74567873e-02,
3.65508593e-02, 3.45751478e-02, 3.36740998e-02,
3.27625023e-02, 3.18417381e-02, 3.09129121e-02,
2.90665673e-02, 2.81454989e-02, 2.72171846e-02,
2.62807950e-02, 2.53342284e-02, 2.43816409e-02,
2.34221736e-02, 2.24541496e-02, 2.08179757e-02,
1.98678098e-02, 1.89113740e-02, 1.79488243e-02,
1.69806146e-02, 1.65158032e-02, 1.55075714e-02,
1.44932106e-02, 1.34746855e-02, 1.24525920e-02,
1.14268067e-02, 1.03968750e-02, 9.36414487e-03,
8.58823755e-03, 7.51804527e-03, 6.44485601e-03,
5.37002690e-03, 4.29398700e-03, 3.31511044e-03,
2.20302298e-03, 1.09069996e-03, -2.27320426e-05,
-1.16892664e-03, -2.31490869e-03, -3.46060569e-03,
-4.74178052e-03, -5.91852523e-03, -7.09360822e-03,
-8.26683115e-03, -9.43736653e-03, -1.06042682e-02,
-1.17686419e-02, -1.33107457e-02, -1.45010352e-02,
-1.56869180e-02, -1.68693838e-02, -1.80464175e-02,
-1.97732638e-02, -2.09722818e-02, -2.21650612e-02,
-2.40185758e-02, -2.52303300e-02, -2.71803154e-02,
-2.84115598e-02, -3.04489552e-02, -3.16936647e-02,
-3.29299358e-02, -3.50861051e-02, -3.63332401e-02,
-3.85745058e-02, -3.98348648e-02, -4.21660006e-02,
-4.34302610e-02, -4.46836493e-02, -4.59254575e-02,
-4.71530952e-02, -4.96209305e-02, -4.95594200e-02,
-5.07435074e-02, -5.19101301e-02, -5.16977894e-02,
-5.14280802e-02, -5.11057669e-02, -5.07251169e-02,
-5.16985297e-02, -5.12126585e-02, -5.06852098e-02,
-5.15589749e-02, -5.09397027e-02, -5.17615499e-02,
-5.10672514e-02, -5.18313966e-02, -5.25816754e-02,
-5.33179227e-02, -5.40360028e-02, -5.47358953e-02,
-5.54213064e-02, -5.77400978e-02, -5.84092053e-02,
-5.90603644e-02, -6.14284845e-02, -6.38379284e-02,
-6.62872262e-02, -6.69166162e-02, -6.93865431e-02,
-7.18947674e-02, -7.44284962e-02, -7.69969804e-02,
-7.96063191e-02, -8.01834105e-02, -8.28053535e-02,
-8.54623715e-02, -8.59961071e-02, -8.86660185e-02,
-8.91520913e-02, -9.18335218e-02, -9.45402708e-02,
-9.49610563e-02, -9.76401856e-02, -1.00332460e-01,
-1.03032191e-01, -1.03358935e-01, -1.06040606e-01,
-1.06322470e-01, -1.08984284e-01, -1.09195131e-01,
-1.11833426e-01, -1.11994247e-01, -1.14596404e-01,
-1.17192554e-01, -1.17248317e-01])
yp = np.array([ -3.90948536e-05, -2.12984775e-03, -4.31095583e-03,
-6.58019633e-03, -8.93758156e-03, -1.11568100e-02,
-1.36444162e-02, -1.62222092e-02, -1.88895170e-02,
-2.16446498e-02, -2.49629308e-02, -2.79508857e-02,
-3.16029501e-02, -3.54376380e-02, -3.87881494e-02,
-4.22310942e-02, -4.41873802e-02, -4.85246067e-02,
-4.68663315e-02, -4.60459599e-02, -4.86676408e-02,
-5.12750434e-02, -5.38586293e-02, -5.54310799e-02,
-5.79452426e-02, -5.93547929e-02, -6.06497762e-02,
-6.18505946e-02, -6.29584706e-02, -6.39609234e-02,
-6.48713094e-02, -6.44090476e-02, -6.51181556e-02,
-6.57260659e-02, -6.62541381e-02, -6.52943568e-02,
-6.56184758e-02, -6.58578685e-02, -6.60229010e-02,
-6.76012689e-02, -6.76366183e-02, -6.76004442e-02,
-6.74972483e-02, -6.73282385e-02, -6.86657097e-02,
-6.83738036e-02, -6.80140059e-02, -6.92366190e-02,
-6.87491258e-02, -6.82071471e-02, -6.76134579e-02,
-6.86669494e-02, -6.79695621e-02, -6.72259327e-02,
-6.64391135e-02, -6.56069234e-02, -6.64563885e-02,
-6.55361171e-02, -6.45783892e-02, -6.18312378e-02,
-6.07850085e-02, -5.80009440e-02, -5.52383021e-02,
-5.24888121e-02, -4.97523554e-02, -4.54714570e-02,
-3.98863362e-02, -3.73592876e-02, -3.48720213e-02,
-3.37707235e-02, -3.26655171e-02, -3.15625118e-02,
-3.04616664e-02, -3.06508019e-02, -2.95344258e-02,
-2.96968330e-02, -2.98505905e-02, -2.87101259e-02,
-2.88391064e-02, -2.89597166e-02, -2.77967360e-02,
-2.78958771e-02, -2.79854740e-02, -2.80670276e-02,
-2.81405467e-02, -2.82051366e-02, -2.69913041e-02,
-2.70365186e-02, -2.70739448e-02, -2.83768113e-02,
-2.83979671e-02, -2.84108899e-02, -2.84155794e-02,
-2.84104617e-02, -2.96993141e-02, -2.96767995e-02,
-2.96453017e-02, -3.09305120e-02, -3.08782748e-02,
-3.08172540e-02, -3.07460634e-02, -3.06652277e-02,
-3.05756546e-02, -3.04773301e-02, -3.03684498e-02,
-3.02505329e-02, -3.01240628e-02, -2.87032761e-02,
-2.85638294e-02, -2.84161924e-02, -2.82602014e-02,
-2.80957411e-02, -2.79220043e-02, -2.65224371e-02,
-2.63408455e-02, -2.61506690e-02, -2.59523304e-02,
-2.57465736e-02, -2.55333569e-02, -2.53114227e-02,
-2.50819674e-02, -2.48453976e-02, -2.46014650e-02,
-2.43490672e-02, -2.40896946e-02, -2.38232320e-02,
-2.35495727e-02, -2.32681400e-02, -1.11708561e-01,
-1.07398522e-01, -2.29799277e-02, -1.10281290e-01,
-1.06025945e-01, -1.06025945e-01, -1.01847844e-01,
-2.26850806e-02, -1.08812919e-01, -1.04614895e-01,
-1.00492396e-01, -9.64256156e-02, -2.23830803e-02,
-1.01124594e-01, -9.11212826e-02, -2.20738630e-02,
-1.03723227e-01, -9.96804013e-02, -9.57062055e-02,
-9.17682599e-02, -9.17682599e-02, -8.78935733e-02,
-8.78935733e-02, -8.40962884e-02, -2.17583603e-02,
-9.82127298e-02, -9.42965108e-02, -8.65980524e-02,
-8.28570139e-02, -2.14365508e-02, -9.28460674e-02,
-8.71354106e-02, -8.34157663e-02, -7.97743543e-02,
-2.11075333e-02, -8.39100274e-02, -8.02849723e-02,
-8.02849723e-02, -7.67428202e-02, -7.67428202e-02,
-7.32724167e-02, -2.07721464e-02, -7.72159766e-02,
-7.37663681e-02, -7.37663681e-02, -7.03828404e-02,
-2.04308432e-02, -7.42042591e-02, -7.08482147e-02,
-7.08482147e-02, -6.75385453e-02, -2.00834820e-02,
-7.12338454e-02, -6.47417418e-02, -2.06352744e-02,
-6.99333169e-02, -6.35600774e-02, -5.30876202e-02,
-4.88515872e-02, -4.88515872e-02, -4.21763073e-02,
-4.21763073e-02, -3.96425097e-02, -2.02588101e-02,
-6.70368116e-02, -6.08364913e-02, -6.08364913e-02,
-5.78440553e-02, -5.78440553e-02, -5.34994049e-02,
-5.34994049e-02, -3.52908904e-02, -1.98763502e-02,
-6.26583213e-02, -3.23368135e-02, -1.94880238e-02,
-5.99037138e-02, -2.85040222e-02, -1.90931928e-02,
-5.72132575e-02, -2.89247783e-02, -1.95297821e-02,
-5.32198482e-02, -2.82971986e-02, -1.91058177e-02,
-4.94013681e-02, -2.86515116e-02, -2.47888430e-02,
-2.20618305e-02, -1.86758942e-02, -4.45232330e-02,
-2.79827472e-02, -2.51286391e-02, -2.06919011e-02,
-1.82397645e-02, -3.76607947e-02, -2.63609122e-02,
-2.45208701e-02, -1.93767971e-02, -1.85788804e-02,
-3.56379420e-02, -2.56998805e-02, -2.39058698e-02,
-1.88908564e-02, -1.81130913e-02, -3.26595065e-02,
-2.50304222e-02, -2.32829732e-02, -3.07966353e-02,
-2.52257065e-02, -2.26527986e-02, -2.80693713e-02,
-2.53799880e-02, -2.28350066e-02, -2.21686432e-02,
-2.22782703e-02, -2.15723084e-02, -2.16081542e-02,
-2.15998200e-02, -2.08220272e-02, -2.07341864e-02,
-1.99180705e-02, -1.97463091e-02, -1.95241512e-02,
-1.86330762e-02, -1.83210810e-02, -1.73881714e-02,
-1.64501676e-02, -1.55073488e-02, -1.45603397e-02,
-1.36076891e-02, -1.26514336e-02, -1.16918550e-02,
-1.07281971e-02, -9.76103257e-03, -8.79150351e-03,
-7.81935696e-03, -6.84417527e-03, -5.86703766e-03,
-4.88857954e-03, -3.90851347e-03, -2.92690669e-03,
-1.94445885e-03, -9.62077293e-04, 2.10973681e-05,
1.00443470e-03, 1.98670872e-03, 2.96920518e-03,
3.95065293e-03, 4.93054490e-03, 5.90896238e-03,
6.88594418e-03, 7.86095305e-03, 8.83291761e-03,
9.80227952e-03, 1.11168744e-02, 1.21109612e-02,
1.31014370e-02, 1.40884671e-02, 1.50714343e-02,
1.65579859e-02, 1.75619959e-02, 1.85609524e-02,
1.95539892e-02, 2.05406220e-02, 2.15208623e-02,
2.31958067e-02, 2.41936890e-02, 2.51825785e-02,
2.69676402e-02, 2.79735240e-02, 2.89676199e-02,
3.08600313e-02, 3.18685118e-02, 3.28673845e-02,
3.38531747e-02, 3.48305552e-02, 3.57981735e-02,
3.67545357e-02, 3.76978426e-02, 3.86308181e-02,
3.95533112e-02, 4.04626970e-02, 4.13583593e-02,
4.22429533e-02, 4.31163338e-02, 4.39732984e-02,
4.48174616e-02, 4.56497573e-02, 4.64690781e-02,
4.72699006e-02, 4.80584575e-02, 4.88339015e-02,
4.95941309e-02, 5.03364921e-02, 4.95646923e-02,
5.02584615e-02, 5.09357803e-02, 5.15956682e-02,
5.22416815e-02, 5.13017754e-02, 5.18954788e-02,
5.24741267e-02, 5.30389590e-02, 5.35886852e-02,
5.24828002e-02, 5.29815950e-02, 5.34658214e-02,
5.39333680e-02, 5.43819816e-02, 5.48154596e-02,
5.52339801e-02, 5.56342267e-02, 5.42908141e-02,
5.46458325e-02, 5.49864909e-02, 5.53070690e-02,
5.56106186e-02, 5.76746395e-02, 5.79561804e-02,
5.82151857e-02, 5.84584712e-02, 5.86858866e-02,
5.88950787e-02, 5.90831689e-02, 5.92552324e-02,
6.12619766e-02, 6.14026109e-02, 6.15224608e-02,
6.16256880e-02, 6.17123394e-02, 6.36720486e-02,
6.37186812e-02, 6.37481408e-02, 6.56861133e-02,
6.56722393e-02, 6.56407664e-02, 6.55917721e-02,
6.74743714e-02, 6.73786194e-02, 6.72646677e-02,
6.71325153e-02, 6.69773741e-02, 6.68003322e-02,
6.66053297e-02, 6.83473413e-02, 6.81027202e-02,
6.78376164e-02, 6.75542903e-02, 6.72524243e-02,
6.88634515e-02, 6.85066915e-02, 6.81318613e-02,
6.96716731e-02, 6.92387957e-02, 7.07292209e-02,
7.02467261e-02, 7.16584645e-02, 7.11134550e-02,
7.05499862e-02, 7.18681370e-02, 7.12419450e-02,
7.24822144e-02, 7.17989089e-02, 7.29694293e-02,
7.22180480e-02, 7.14476517e-02, 7.06588875e-02,
6.98486903e-02, 7.08078412e-02, 6.81567317e-02,
6.72843393e-02, 6.63881936e-02, 6.37899997e-02,
6.12404950e-02, 5.87433383e-02, 5.62902969e-02,
5.53950962e-02, 5.29895052e-02, 5.06437557e-02,
4.97490264e-02, 4.74631181e-02, 4.65678359e-02,
4.43551128e-02, 4.34554011e-02, 4.25440351e-02,
4.16213883e-02, 4.06842153e-02, 3.97338457e-02,
3.87727819e-02, 3.89122376e-02, 3.78978623e-02,
3.68719281e-02, 3.68766567e-02, 3.68230044e-02,
3.67095055e-02, 3.55465346e-02, 3.53200609e-02,
3.50311849e-02, 3.46717730e-02, 3.42461153e-02,
3.37555022e-02, 3.23610029e-02, 3.17505933e-02,
3.10701527e-02, 2.95754797e-02, 2.87735213e-02,
2.72210019e-02, 2.62970023e-02, 2.52956273e-02,
2.36404433e-02, 2.25053642e-02, 2.12889860e-02,
1.99902757e-02, 1.81872330e-02, 1.67574555e-02,
1.49054892e-02, 1.33429656e-02, 1.14391250e-02,
9.74643800e-03, 7.79267351e-03, 5.96714375e-03,
4.05355227e-03, 2.00672241e-03])
# -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Use scipy to interpolate.
xp = np.r_[xp, xp[0]]
yp = np.r_[yp, yp[0]]
tck, u = interpolate.splprep([xp, yp], s=0, k=1, per=True)
xi, yi = interpolate.splev(np.linspace(0, 1, 1000), tck)
# -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Plot result
fig = plt.figure()
ax = plt.subplot(111)
ax.plot(xp, yp, '.', markersize=2)
ax.plot(xi, yi, alpha=0.5)
plt.show()
I get the following error on one machine (MacOS),
---> tck, u = interpolate.splprep([xp, yp], s=0, k=1, per=True)
SystemError: <built-in function _parcur> returned NULL without setting an error
And this error on another machine (Ubuntu),
----> tck, u = interpolate.splprep([xp, yp], s=0, k=1, per=True)
ValueError: Invalid inputs.
interpolate.splprep uses the FORTRAN parcur routine from FITPACK (from the documentation).
My questions are -
Why does the code work for different datasets? e.g. xp = np.array([0.1, 0.2, 0.3, 0.4]) yp = np.array([-0.1, -0.3, -0.4, 0.2]) and not for this particular one? What does the error mean?
How can I get this to work? (Using this method or any other method) i.e. either interpolate a curve or filter the outliers ...
Out of curiosity, why is the error machine (and OS) dependent?
This is how the data looks when plotted, I think you can guess which curve I'd like to interpolate to (and which outliers I'd like to remove, if possible)
Fitpack has a fit if it two consecutive inputs are identical. The error happens deep enough that it depends on how the libraries were compiled and linked, hence the assortment of errors.
For example, xp[147:149], yp[147:149] (and several others):
(array([ 0.07705342, 0.07705342]), array([-0.09176826, -0.09176826]))
These are okay:
okay = np.where(np.abs(np.diff(xp)) + np.abs(np.diff(yp)) > 0)
xp = np.r_[xp[okay], xp[-1], xp[0]]
yp = np.r_[yp[okay], yp[-1], yp[0]]
# the rest of your code
I add the last point back because the output of diff is always one element shorter, so the last one needs to be included manually. (And then of course, you put the 0th point again for periodicity)
Cutting off the weird part
This is my attempt to cut off the weird extruding part of the dataset. It uses a Gaussian filter from ndimage. The original points xp, yp are kept this time; the filtered ones are xn, yn.
jump = np.sqrt(np.diff(xp)**2 + np.diff(yp)**2)
smooth_jump = ndimage.gaussian_filter1d(jump, 5, mode='wrap') # window of size 5 is arbitrary
limit = 2*np.median(smooth_jump) # factor 2 is arbitrary
xn, yn = xp[:-1], yp[:-1]
xn = xn[(jump > 0) & (smooth_jump < limit)]
yn = yn[(jump > 0) & (smooth_jump < limit)]
So, we remove not only duplicate points but also the points where the values jump around too much. The rest goes as before, interpolation is built out of xn, yn now. I plot original points for comparison with the new (red) curve):
ax.plot(xp, yp, 'o', markersize=2)
ax.plot(xi, yi, 'r', alpha=0.5)